My San Francisco Home

Painted Ceilings and the Wrong Yellow

In my San Francisco home, one dark color does most of the work. Benjamin Moore Cheating Heart covers the ceilings of the open plan living room/kitchen. We're used to seeing dark ceilings in restaurants, but not in homes, so the space tends to make a bold statement with guests.

The walls are BM Gray Owl at 50%. Behind the TV, an arch in BM French Horn gives the room its focal point.

The Wrong YellowRoom by RoomThe Garden WallLaura's FavoritesThe Forest House

Sample the Colors in This House

Try them on your own walls before you paint. Each one links to a peel-and-stick sample from Samplize.

Swatches are approximate. Color Catalog may earn a commission when you order samples through these links.

Laura's San Francisco living room with a dark Cheating Heart ceiling, Gray Owl at 50% walls and a mustard French Horn arch behind the TV
My living room: Cheating Heart on the ceiling, Gray Owl at 50% on the walls and French Horn in the arch.

Cheating Heart (Benjamin Moore 1617) · ceilings

Gray Owl at 50% (OC-52) · walls

French Horn (195) · arch

I still get constant compliments on the dark ceiling, more than 10 years later. It's one of the best features of the house, and it really helped turn a 1995 condo townhouse into a place with character and "wow factor."
Order a Cheating Heart sampleFrench Horn sampleGray Owl sample

Why This Site Exists

The Wrong Yellow

That back wall used to be Cheating Heart, like the ceiling. But after I got divorced I needed fresh energy and a less fatiguing space.

Before: the living room back wall and ceiling both painted dark Cheating Heart, with white bookcases
Before: Cheating Heart on the back wall and the ceiling.
Before: the dark living room seen from the other end, with a leather sofa and a striped rug
Before, from the other end of the room.

I worked with a feng shui expert, Johanna Sprague, whom I highly recommend. She suggested warming and lightening the wall color: she said something warmer would bring me more energy than such a dark blue space, which felt enveloping in its darkness.

So I picked a bright yellow, and I hated it. I had the painter repaint it in French Horn, and it was better but I still didn't like it.

The living room wall painted a bright yellow under the dark ceiling
The first yellow. Ack! I thought I wanted school bus yellow but I hated it.
A painter on a ladder repainting the bright yellow wall
My patient team repainting. My SF go-to is Hank Garcia Painting.
The whole wall in French Horn with a gallery wall, running right up to the dark ceiling
The second yellow, French Horn. Still not right but I couldn't figure out why.

My stylist friend Larkin Brown came over and figured it out: yellow and navy look very traditional or collegiate right next to each other, which was killing the effect for me. So I added 50% Gray Owl to create the arch.
You can see my process below! There's probably a better way, but I got it done with newsprint and painter's tape.

Blue painter's tape marking out an arch on the yellow wall, with newsprint templates
Taping out the arch with newsprint and painter's tape.
The finished living room: a French Horn arch behind the TV, Gray Owl at 50% above it and a dark Cheating Heart ceiling
After: French Horn in the arch, Gray Owl at 50% above it and Cheating Heart on the ceiling.

Keeping French Horn in the arch and adding Gray Owl at 50% above it is what made it work. With a little space and breathing room between the yellow and the navy, I've been really, really happy with how the colors look together.

A cheetah lamp, yellow books and a plant on the bookcase in front of the French Horn arch
Up close: French Horn in the arch, with yellow accessories accenting it.

My point: I picked the wrong yellow first, and I spent a lot of money having it repainted. That's a big part of why I made this site, to help you find the tried-and-true colors and get it right the first time.

Sample Before You Paint

Yellows, greens, pinks, reds, terracottas and oranges are the trickiest colors. They can look really different in person than they do on screen, so I definitely recommend testing them first. It's way easier to use Samplize than brushing out sample paint.

Room by Room

The San Francisco living room looking toward the kitchen, under a dark Cheating Heart ceiling, with a French Horn arch on the right

Open Plan: Living Room

Cheating Heart · ceiling

French Horn · arch

The San Francisco kitchen with white cabinets, a butcher-block island and a dark Cheating Heart ceiling around the skylight

Open Plan: Kitchen

Cheating Heart · ceiling and inside the skylight

French doors open to a deck under a dark Cheating Heart ceiling, with a dark stair railing on the right

Open Plan: Toward the Deck

Cheating Heart · ceiling and stair railing

White Dove · trim

A stairwell with a dark Cheating Heart ceiling, Gray Owl at 50% walls, a skylight, tall windows looking onto a tree and a dark blue painting

Stairwell

Cheating Heart · ceiling

A covered deck with Black Bean Soup siding, two pink hammock chairs, a macrame screen and a blue rug

Lower Deck

Black Bean Soup (2130-10) · siding

The dark brown gives a nice masculine, mountainy, cabiny vibe and doesn't feel as played out as navy or dark green.

A kids room with Shadow walls, a wood bunk bed, a striped loveseat and a blue rug

Kids' Room

Shadow · walls

The kids wanted a purple room when they were tweens. Shadow was the one I could live with too, because it felt more sophisticated.

A bathroom with Parchment walls and a Coral Odyssey ceiling

Bathroom

Parchment · walls

Coral Odyssey (Sherwin-Williams) · ceiling

Neutral walls with a pink ceiling uplit casting a sunset glow on the whole room.

A bathroom with light gray walls, white square tile, a round wood mirror and a white vanity

Second Bathroom

Metropolitan or Gray Owl · walls

Honestly, I don't remember which gray this was! Can't go wrong with either of these.

Laura's bedroom with Hollingsworth Green walls, a White Dove ceiling and a peach quilt

My Bedroom

White Dove · ceiling

If I had it to do over again, I'd paint the ceilings Hollingsworth Green too.

The treatment room with Hollingsworth Green walls, white cabinets, a butcher-block counter and a large beanbag

Treatment Room

White Dove · ceiling

Swatches are approximate. Order samples to see the real colors on your wall.

Surprise and Delight

The Garden Wall

This mural is in the courtyard of my San Francisco house, across from the hot tub. I wanted that space to feel like it could be at a hotel in Buenos Aires or Mexico City: something really vibrant.

The Colors, Top to Bottom (All Benjamin Moore)

Luminous Days

Super White I did want a really bright white here.

Soft Salmon I've also used it on a gate.

Meadowlands Green Now that I know better, Harrisburg Green is my minty green.

Starry Night Blue

Fan Coral

Summer Day

Steamed Spinach I've used it many times, and I love it.

The garden wall in progress: chalk guide arcs across the gray wall, blue tape marking each scallop, and the first row painted
In progress: chalk guide arcs and tape marks, with the first row of scallops painted.
The finished mural of scalloped stripes in mustard, pale blue, peach, seafoam, navy, coral, light blue and dark green
Finished.

More of My Colors

Laura's treatment room with Hollingsworth Green walls and a mustard quilt

Laura's Favorites

The Benjamin Moore colors I use over and over.

The forest house living room with Swiss Coffee walls and ceiling beams painted in eight colors

The Forest House

Swiss Coffee walls, eight colorful beams and Evening Dove cabinets.

Need Help Choosing?

I'll help you find the right colors for your home or business.

Work with me

Color Catalog may earn a commission when you order samples through the links on this page.